Why Cakewalk by BandLab is the Best Free DAW (and Where It Falls Short)
For music producers on a budget, Cakewalk by BandLab stands out as an exceptional, completely free DAW (Digital Audio Workstation) that brings professional-grade features to your fingertips. While paid DAWs like Ableton Live, Logic Pro, or Studio One are often the go-to choices for many, Cakewalk provides a robust set of tools without costing a penny. However, like all software, it has its pros and cons. Let’s dive into what makes Cakewalk such a top contender for free DAWs and where it could improve.
1. Budget – Rating: 10/10
One of Cakewalk’s most significant advantages is its price—absolutely free! While many high-quality DAWs come with hefty price tags, Cakewalk offers professional-grade audio production tools without any financial investment. From recording and editing to mixing and mastering, it covers all the essentials, making it the perfect DAW for producers on a tight budget. Whether you’re a hobbyist or a budding professional, Cakewalk gives you the tools you need without the financial burden. In this category, Cakewalk is truly unbeatable.
2. Operating System Compatibility – Rating: 6/10
Unfortunately, Cakewalk is currently only available for Windows users, which significantly limits its appeal. If you’re a macOS user, you’re out of luck. While there are some workarounds like using virtual machines or Bootcamp, they require extra effort and technical know-how. With macOS becoming increasingly popular among music producers, this could be a dealbreaker for some. Cakewalk has the potential to enhance its appeal by providing a native macOS version. However, if you’re eager to use this DAW on a Mac, there are still methods available for installation. If you’re interested, you can check out my guide here.
- Music Genre and Workflow – Rating: 8/10
Cakewalk excels at audio recording and MIDI editing, making it an excellent choice for genres that require a lot of detailed work, like rock, pop, and orchestral music. The DAW provides unlimited tracks, robust MIDI functionality, and a pro-channel strip with analog-style effects, all of which are perfect for nuanced production. However, it may not be the best DAW for electronic music or live performance. For those workflows, DAWs like Ableton Live might offer a more intuitive experience. Still, for traditional studio recording and detailed composition, Cakewalk is a solid choice.
-
- Features and Plugins – Rating: 9/10
When it comes to features, Cakewalk shines. It includes unlimited tracks, sophisticated MIDI editing tools, and a pro-channel strip with analog-style effects. Additionally, it supports third-party VSTs, (both VST2 and VST3) including both 64-bit and older 32-bit plugins. This means you (almost) never miss out on using your favourite plugins inside Cakewalk (Sonar). While its bundled instruments and effects are solid, they don’t quite match the premium level of some other DAWs. However, considering the price (free), this is a minor issue. You can easily expand its capabilities with your own plugins, which compensates for the lack of premium bundled content.
- Learning Curve – Rating: 7/10
Despite being free, Cakewalk comes with a lot of features that may overwhelm beginners. While the interface is user-friendly for those who are used to DAWs, its depth and complexity mean that new users might need to invest significant time to master it. This isn’t a dealbreaker for those with prior experience in DAWs, but if you’re completely new to music production, it may take a bit longer to get up to speed. Thankfully, there are plenty of tutorials and a strong user community to help you along the way.
- Hardware Integration – Rating: 8/10
Cakewalk integrates well with most external hardware, including MIDI controllers and audio interfaces, making it a solid choice for users who require hardware integration. However, it lacks some of the advanced features offered by other DAWs, such as Ableton Live or Studio One, when it comes to hardware-specific functionality. But for most users, Cakewalk handles MIDI and audio interfaces just fine, making it a reliable option for home studios.
- Trial Versions – Rating: N/A
Cakewalk doesn’t have a trial period since it’s completely free to use – forever (or at least that’s what they have committed). This is a massive advantage for users who want to test out a DAW before making any commitment. The fact that Cakewalk is free means there’s no risk involved, which is particularly appealing to new users or those who are exploring the DAW world for the first time.
- Community and Support – Rating: 8/10
Cakewalk has a strong user community, especially since its acquisition by BandLab. With regular updates and an active forum, there’s no shortage of resources for troubleshooting and learning new tips and tricks. However, as with any software, some users report occasional bugs or stability issues. Also, the DAW requires reactivation after a while, which could be a problem if you don’t have an internet connection on your studio computer. While these aren’t major drawbacks, they do affect the overall experience. Still, the support and community behind Cakewalk ensure that most issues can be addressed quickly.
Overall Rating: 8/10
Cakewalk by BandLab is arguably the best free DAW available today. It offers a professional-level feature set that suits many genres and workflows, particularly for those focused on audio recording and MIDI editing. While it’s not as intuitive for electronic music or live performances, it remains an excellent choice for budget-conscious music producers who primarily need robust recording and editing tools.
The major downside of Cakewalk is its lack of compatibility with macOS, which limits its accessibility. Additionally, while its bundled instruments and effects aren’t the best on the market, the ability to add third-party plugins easily makes up for this. Overall, Cakewalk provides tremendous value for no cost, making it an easy choice for those seeking high-quality audio production tools without breaking the bank.
Conclusion
If you’re just starting out or if you’re an experienced producer looking for a free yet powerful DAW, Cakewalk by BandLab is hard to beat. While it may not have the polish of some paid alternatives, its feature set, coupled with the fact that it’s completely free, make it a fantastic choice for many producers.
Want to learn Cakewalk Live?
Interactive, fun sessions that help you ace your skills.
Book Live Session